WALLS OF SILENCE
SECTION 9 TITLE 9.6 EXPLANATION OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE DEFINITIONS AND CORE
TACTICS
W |
hile often associated with physical violence, domestic abuse takes many other forms that can be equally damaging and insidious. The Power and Control Wheel—a model developed by the Domestic Abuse Intervention Project in Duluth, Minnesota—outlines eight primary tactics used by abusers to dominate their victims. Each tactic operates to enforce control, with physical and sexual violence acting as reinforcing tools to sustain this power. Understanding these tactics is essential for identifying domestic violence and aiding those affected in recognizing and resisting these patterns.
Subpart 1. Coercion & Threats
Abusers use coercion and threats to create fear and ensure compliance. This tactic involves the use of intimidation, which may include threats of harm, such as:
A. Threats to leave the victim or take away children.
B. Threats to commit suicide if the victim attempts to leave.
C. Threats of reporting the victim to immigration authorities or the police.
This dynamic is manipulative, as it places the victim in a state of ongoing anxiety, often fearing dire consequences if they don’t comply with the abuser’s demands. By doing so, the abuser keeps control over their partner, effectively trapping them within the relationship.
Subpart 2. Intimidation
Intimidation is a psychological tool used to instill fear and submission. This may involve:
A. Destroying personal belongings, punching walls, or engaging in physically aggressive behavior.
B. Using gestures, postures, or facial expressions to convey a threat of violence.
C. Displaying weapons or making it known that they are accessible to the abuser.
These actions serve to keep the victim in a constant state of alertness, anticipating potential outbursts. The fear of violence, whether it happens or not, is a form of control that limits the victim’s freedom and independence.
Subpart 3. Emotional Abuse
Emotional abuse attacks the victim’s self-worth and mental well-being, often involving:
A. Verbal insults, name-calling, and public humiliation.
B. Belittling or dismissing the victim’s opinions, ideas, or accomplishments.
C. Gaslighting, or making the victim question their reality, memories, or mental stability.
This form of abuse is particularly insidious because it erodes the victim’s confidence over time. Emotional abuse can lead victims to believe they are unworthy or incapable, further isolating them and making them more dependent on the abuser.
Subpart 4. Isolation
Isolation restricts the victim’s access to support systems, such as friends, family, and community resources. Abusers achieve isolation by:
A. Dictating who the victim can see, speak to, or interact with.
B. Limiting the victim’s freedom to attend social events, school, or work.
C. Controlling the victim’s access to mail, transportation, phone, or internet.
Isolation increases the victim’s dependency on the abuser, as it limits the chances of gaining outside support or alternative perspectives. This tactic often goes hand-in-hand with emotional abuse, as the abuser manipulates the victim into feeling they have no other options.
Subpart 5. Minimizing, Denying, & Blaming
Abusers commonly minimize or deny their abusive behaviors or shift blame onto the victim. Examples include:
A. Dismissing or downplaying the severity of abusive incidents.
B. Claiming the victim “made them do it” or that it was “just a joke.”
C. Denying abuse altogether, making the victim feel like they are overreacting or being irrational.
This tactic keeps victims doubting their perception of reality, often leaving them questioning whether they are, in fact, the cause of the abuse. Minimization, denial, and blame function to manipulate the victim into a mindset where they feel responsible for the abuse, further entrenching the abuser’s control.
Subpart 6. Using Children
For those with children, abusers may use them as tools for control. This can include:
A. Threatening to take the children away or restricting access to them.
B. Undermining the victim’s relationship with the children, perhaps by bad-mouthing them.
C. Using visitation as an opportunity to control or threaten the victim, even if they are no longer living together.
Using children as leverage is devastating, as it not only manipulates the victim but also affects the children’s well-being and relationship with their non-abusive parent. This tactic is particularly cruel, as it can force victims to endure ongoing abuse out of fear for their children’s safety or custody arrangements.
Subpart 7. Economic Abuse
Economic abuse is a tactic that limits the victim’s ability to gain financial independence. This can take various forms, such as:
A. Controlling all financial decisions and denying the victim access to bank accounts.
B. Sabotaging the victim’s ability to work or attend school, which would allow them to earn income.
C. Giving the victim an “allowance” or requiring detailed accounts of their spending.
Financial control makes it extremely difficult for victims to leave, as they lack the resources to support themselves or their children. Economic abuse serves as a powerful barrier to independence, keeping victims financially and psychologically bound to the abuser.
Subpart 8. Male Privilege
Male privilege in abusive relationships is where the abuser enforces traditional gender roles or ideas about male superiority to justify their control. Tactics under this category may include:
A. Making all major decisions, expecting to be obeyed without question.
B. Treating the victim as a servant or assuming an “ownership” attitude toward the victim.
C. Using beliefs about male dominance to justify or excuse abusive behavior.
Although male privilege as a tactic may not apply to every case of domestic violence, it often intersects with cultural beliefs or social norms, allowing the abuser to rationalize their behavior. This abuse of power can further entrench the victim’s belief that their subjugation is inevitable or even deserved.
Subpart 9. Summary Reinforcement Through Physical and Sexual Violence
The eight tactics of the Power and Control Wheel are often backed by physical and sexual violence, creating an environment where threats and intimidation escalate into physical harm. Physical violence can include anything from slapping and punching to life-threatening assaults, while sexual violence might involve forced sexual acts or sexual coercion. By leveraging the threat or reality of violence, abusers reinforce control tactics, making it clear that any resistance could result in immediate harm.
Subpart 10. Legal Implications and Protections
The legal landscape surrounding domestic violence has evolved to recognize the diverse ways in which abuse manifests. In the United States, laws vary by state, but several federal protections exist to assist victims, including the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) and various state-level restraining order provisions. These laws aim to protect survivors from further harm by providing access to protective orders, financial assistance, housing support, and counseling services.
Subpart 11. Key Case Law on Domestic Violence
Legal precedent has played a significant role in shaping protections against domestic violence. Some notable cases include:
1. Castle Rock v. Gonzales (2005) - This Supreme Court case highlighted limitations in holding law enforcement accountable for enforcing restraining orders. The court ruled that a town and its police department were not liable for failing to enforce a restraining order, underscoring the need for systemic reform to better protect survivors.
2. Fulgham v. State (1871) - This case was one of the first in the United States to recognize that husbands did not have the right to physically discipline their wives, representing a crucial step in the historical shift toward criminalizing domestic violence.
3. People v. Humphrey (1996) - In this California case, the court recognized battered woman syndrome as a defense for women accused of harming their abusers, acknowledging the psychological impact of domestic abuse.
While case law and legislation have advanced, the fight for comprehensive protection and support for victims continues. Victims of domestic violence require a combination of legal, social, and emotional support to break free from abusive environments and rebuild their lives. Domestic violence extends beyond physical abuse; it’s a calculated, multi-faceted strategy employed to control and diminish a victim’s autonomy. Recognizing the tactics outlined in the Power and Control Wheel helps victims, advocates, and law enforcement identify abuse beyond bruises and scars, shining a light on the pervasive and often invisible power dynamics that define domestic violence. With a continued commitment to legal reform, community support, and educational initiatives, we can better equip survivors to escape abusive situations and foster resilience in the face of adversity.
Sexual Violence Against Soulaani Women | Grooming | Emotional Abuse | Domestic Abuser | Profile of Abuser | Intimate Non-Personal Abuse
Color-Coded In-Article Highlights Guide
Abuse Type / Highlight Purpose | Color | Meaning & Awareness Context |
Sexual Harassment | Teal | Widely recognized color for sexual violence and harassment awareness. |
Emotional Abuse | Yellow | Yellow symbolizes emotional abuse awareness; used in mental health advocacy contexts. |
Domestic Violence (Physical/Coercive) | Purple | Official domestic violence awareness color; symbolizes strength and survival. |
Acts Against Additional Victims | Orange | Distinct from the main victim, orange signals related but secondary harm; used in social justice campaigns. |
Suggested Articles:
Case Study: The Systemic Failure to Recognize Intimate Non-Personal Abuse
0 comments